Four different claims hide inside the word “understand.”
The claim becomes stronger as you move from a convincing response toward conscious experience. Evidence for one step does not automatically prove the next.
Where the positions divide
The interviews do not offer three answers to one settled definition. They reveal a ladder of claims, from convincing behaviour to internal models to first-person experience.
Start with a position
Perspectives from research, industry, policy, and public life.
Every position links back to the original conversation.
Compare positionsChoose any two people and inspect where their claims align, diverge, or remain unresolved.
After exploring
Record a provisional view, test it, and name what remains unresolved.
Which position is closest to yours?
Choose a provisional position. You can revise it as you examine stronger evidence.
What evidence could change your mind?
A test that can distinguish fluent behaviour, internal representation, agency, embodiment, and subjective experience.
What question comes next?
Four different claims hide inside the word “understand.”
The claim becomes stronger as you move from a convincing response toward conscious experience. Evidence for one step does not automatically prove the next.
Behaviour
The system gives an appropriate response.
World model
The system represents features, locations, movement, or change.
Agency
The system pursues goals, plans, learns, or reflects on its own decisions.
Experience
There is something it feels like to be the system.
Build your position.
Use four checks to turn what you explored into a view you can explain, test, and revise.
- 01Test a claimChoose one
- 02Set the evidence barAnswer
- 03Take a positionChoose
- 04Ask what comes nextWrite
Choose one test for the claims you read.
Open a test to reveal the question it asks of the evidence.
Would this evidence change your view?
Use the proposed test as a threshold, then decide how much it would matter.
A test that can distinguish fluent behaviour, internal representation, agency, embodiment, and subjective experience.
Where do you stand now?
Record your current position. It can change as you open stronger evidence.
Choose the answer that best reflects your position after reading the evidence.
What should be investigated next?
A useful next question names the uncertainty that remains.
Your position so far.
This summary updates as you examine sources and revise your answers.
Your reflections are saved only in this browser. They are never sent to CIF. Export a copy or reset them at any time.
Open a position to begin testing the answer.